Trent in New York--Part III, Historic Hall Apartment House

A 6" x 18" Trent art tile
panel (3-6" tiles) from a fireplace.
(Author's collection)

     To me the most interesting and tantalizing Trent tile installation mentioned in the September 7, 1909 Trenton Evening Times article (see Trent-Part I) was the tiled panels and floor in the "Historic Hall" apartment house in Manhattan. The newspaper article describes these murals as follows: the first tile mural "...produce[d] a picture of New York City...as it appeared in 1407, true to nature and within a space of five feet six inches by four feet six inches... ." The second tile mural "...reproduce[d] an old print showing Harlem, from Morrisania, in 1647, in a panel of three feet six inches by two feet six inches... ." The third tile panel "...present[ed] an accurate likeness of the trees planted in New York by Alexander Hamilton in 1802, inside [a border] of two feet six inches by nine feet... ." Further, "The floor of Historic Hall, in the main corridor, is to be covered with tile, in the design of a damask rug, in 24 colors, embracing a space of ten feet...six inches by eleven feet. The fine, old-fashioned fireplace, too, is to be of tile, and the words Historic Hall in superior ceramic mosaics are to be placed beneath the...mantel." Architect Albert P. Morris designed Manhattan's "Historic Hall" apartment house. The interior, main floor decoration was conceived by Charles B. Upjohn, chief of the design staff at the Trent Tile Company, and the matt-glazed murals were painted by the artist Norman E. Rulon. Ceramist Charles Lawshe oversaw the production of the tiles.
     When I first read of this apartment house, I began searching for it on the internet. All I had was the name, not the address. I found one newspaper article that mentioned the Historic Hall apartments: "Activity Shown In West Side Districts", New York Daily Tribune, May 1, 1910, p. 12, column 2, which placed the building "in St. Nicholas avenue opposite l56th street." I then went to Christopher Gray's excellent website, Office for Metropolitan History, and read his article, A Guide to Researching the History of a New York City Building.
      Since the building was designed by the architect Albert P. Morris and built in 1909, I next searched for the architect's new buildings (NBs) for 1909 and the surrounding years in the "Manhattan NB Database 1900-1986", accessed through Christopher Gray's website. Three new buildings were listed for Albert Morris. The most promising result out of these three buildings was one built in 1909 on the East side of St. Nicholas Avenue, approximately 248 feet North of 155th Street. 
     I then took a trip to St. Nicholas Avenue and 155th Street and roughly measured 248 feet from 155th Street. I found myself in the middle of 156th Street. The building I focused on was at the NE corner of West 156th Street and St. Nicholas Avenue--940 St. Nicholas Avenue. Another building on the SE corner became my second choice--936-938 St. Nicholas Avenue. I managed to gain entry to the ground floors of both buildings, and decided that the three tile murals, "rug" and mantel would have fit better in 940 St. Nicholas Avenue.

     940 St. Nicholas Avenue

Entrance, 940 St. Nicholas Avenue, Manhattan

A large public area on the ground floor near the St. Nicholas Avenue entrance

Entry hallway at the West 156th Street entrance

936-938 St. Nicholas Avenue

Entrance, 936-938 St. Nicholas Avenue

Internal courtyard to apartment entrance

One of the interior hallways

          Trent created at least one other pictorial tile rug that has been described in print, although no photos are known to exist. An undated and unpaged article, "Curious Indian Legend Designed in the 'Mat'" in a Trenton Sunday Advertiser, states:

          I have asked both the Potteries of Trenton Society, which has an excellent database of the ceramic companies operating in Trenton, NJ, and the Tile Heritage Foundation for information about the Kline Barber Shop and the Historic Hall building, but neither had any new information.

     (The Tile Heritage Foundation recently mentioned my historic tile installations website and this blog in their E-Newsletter.)

A Trent fireplace surround recently seen on eBay

American Encaustic Tiling Company--Part II, Artists' Tiles

One of the remaining abandoned AET buildings in Zanesville, OH
(Photo courtesy of Michael Padwee, 2010)

AET Tile Panels

     The AET buildings are now abandoned in Zanesville, Ohio where this company once reigned supreme in ceramic tile production. The AET showrooms in Zanesville may have once rivaled Leon Solon's New York showrooms, but we only have a poor-quality photocopy of a partial photo of a showroom.

        

It is said that Leon Solon decorated the Zanesville showrooms with the same care as his New York showrooms. (Photocopy courtesy of Mike Sims)

     In New York Leon Solon encouraged artists to work in a ceramic medium. Artists, including Solon, designed tile panels and individual tiles from other mediums. This was not new in the art tile industry. Beginning in the 1880s the Low Art Tile Works of Chelsea, Massachusetts, for instance, had a working relationship with members of the "Tile Club". The artist and Tile Club member Elihu Vedder designed a celebratory art tile, which was produced by Low, for the 150th performance of the play "Esmeralda" in 1882.

Esmeralda tile designed by Elihu Vedder

     Even prior to the advent of Leon Solon at AET, large art tile panels were produced under the supervision of Felix Alcan, the head of the AET art studio. One such panel was "a reproduction in [mosaic] tile of the famous old German painting 'Cupids Bearing the Crest.' There are about 23,000 separate pieces of tiling in the work and the cost...is said to [be] $5000. There are nine cupids in the panel. Each wears a garland of flowers and they are bearing a crest or crown into a sky of pale blue, which is dotted here and there with small, fleecy clouds, making a beautiful background. The features of the cupids, even to the coloring of the eyes and the dimples in their cheeks, is brought out perfectly...and, at a distance, under proper lighting conditions, the panel looks like an oil painting." (Quoted from The Mantel Tile and Grate Monthly, Vol. 2, No. 11, May 1908, pp. 29-30) Sadly, there is no image of this lost art tile panel.
     The artist Arthur Crisp designed at least two art tile panels for Solon which were produced by AET and exhibited by the New York Architectural League. (Solon was very much in favor of polychromed, artistic tilework being used in architecture, and he wrote a series of articles explaining his theories, "Principles of Polychromy in Architecture", which were published in 1922 in the Architectural Record.)
     The first of Crisp's panels was titled "Two Green Elephants" and showed two elephants facing each other carrying baskets of flowers; there was a tree in the center of the panel with two fancy birds sitting on bottom branches and other birds on the top branches. The panel consisted of 40 tiles arranged in 4 horizontal rows of 
10 tiles each. We are not certain of the size of the panel; each individual tile could have been be 6”, 8”, 9” or 12” square. But, if the tiles were 6" square like the other panel, this piece would have been 5 1/2' x 2 1/2'.

     The other panel, "The Sacred Dragon" depicted a Chinese dragon facing true left. This panel was approximately 8' long x 2' high and consisted of 64 tiles--6” faience tiles, arranged horizontally in four rows of 16 tiles.  (Descriptions and images from: "The Architectural League of New York and Its Relations to Crafts and Manufactures" by H. Van Buren Magonigle, The American Architect, Volume 121, No. 2387, Feb. 15, 1922, pp. 166-167 and Year Book of the Architectural League of New York..., Vol. 37, 1922)

     Leon Solon, himself an artist, also designed a number of art tile panels for AET. Some were reproduced in architectural magazines or as ads, others were exhibited in his AET showrooms in Manhattan.                                             

"The Dancing Women" 

     One of Solon's panels was titled the "Sun God". This panel was created about 1915 and its size is not known. "The very interesting composition, Sun God panel, has been exhibited by the Architectural League, but has not been reproduced in any art magazine before. The possibilities of such faience decoration are more apparent when the colour scheme is seen, and that unfortunately dees not appear in the half-tone. The jewel-like quality of the tile mosaic against a dull red background gives a most harmonious result, and should be seen by every architect of taste. The Sun God panel is derived from the Maya Art, examples of which still remain in Yucatan." (The International Studio, Vol. LVII, No. 226, December 1915, John Lane Co., New York, “In the Galleries”, pp. LXVI, LXVIII) 

(From: H. Van Buren Magonigle, "A Potter and His Work", The Architectural Record,
Vol. XLV, No. 4, April 1919, Serial No. 247, pp. 303-311.)

     Solon designed a tile panel of a trident-throwing warrior,  which is only known because it was featured in color on the January 1919 cover of The Architectural Record (Vol. XLV, No. 1, Serial No. 244).

"The Warrior"

     Two panels which were most probably designed by Solon when he first became the art director of AET, still exist on a building facade at 2840-2844 Atlantic Avenue, Brooklyn. 

An architectural drawing of the Empire State Dairy plant, dated 1913 and signed by the architect, Otto Strack (1857-1935)

                                                                                                                                                                   

     In 1924 the Borden Dairy Company purchased this building, and the panels fit in with the products of the building's new owners. (The New York Times, Feb. 1, 1924) These may be the largest existing AET art tile panels in the United States, but they were only protected by the good will of the building owner, who has recently died.

     These are two tile panels, each consisting of 68, 6", 9” or 12” square tiles. If each tile is 6" square, then each panel is 2 1/2' x 7'. The panels are polychromed, high relief, majolica tiles; 5 tiles across by 13 down with 3 tiles in a bottom 14th row. The panels are situated near the top of the building and are separated by three large windows. A request for evaluation for landmark status was sent to the Landmarks Preservation Commission on July 6, 2012. Update: July 12, the LPC staff will review my request and material.